Health Ministers from Non-BJP States Criticize WHO’s Excess Death Estimates
Health ministers representing several non-BJP states, including Maharashtra, Jharkhand, Tamil Nadu, Delhi, and Punjab, have voiced strong objections to the World Health Organization’s (WHO) estimates of additional deaths linked to the COVID-19 pandemic in India.
Flawed Mathematical Assumptions: Health Ministers Unite Against WHO’s Figures
During the 14th Conference of the Central Council of Health and Family Welfare (CCHFW) held in Gujarat, ministers from around 20 states and union territories unanimously rejected the WHO’s estimates of excess deaths caused by COVID-19, terming the mathematical assumptions flawed.
Transparent Recording of COVID-19 Fatalities: Ministers Question WHO’s Accuracy
The health ministers emphasized that COVID-19-related deaths are systematically recorded in India according to legal processes. The resolution passed during the conference expressed disappointment with the WHO’s “exorbitant estimates of excess mortality” during the pandemic.
Robust Death Registration System: India’s Response to WHO’s Claims
The Council highlighted India’s comprehensive death registration system governed by the “Registration of Births and Deaths Act 1969,” which ensures accurate documentation of deaths due to all causes. The ministers urged the central government to address these concerns with the WHO on a global scale.
COVID-19, India’s health ministers, WHO estimates
Health ministers from non-BJP states in India have raised serious doubts about the World Health Organization’s (WHO) estimates of additional deaths attributed to the COVID-19 pandemic in the country. These ministers, representing states such as Maharashtra, Jharkhand, Tamil Nadu, Delhi, and Punjab, have united in their criticism of the WHO’s figures.
During the recent 14th Conference of the Central Council of Health and Family Welfare (CCHFW) held in Gujarat, health ministers from approximately 20 states and union territories gathered to discuss the WHO’s estimates. They unanimously rejected the figures, citing what they consider to be flawed mathematical assumptions underlying the calculations. The ministers emphasized that India has a well-established and transparent process for recording deaths due to all causes, including COVID-19.
The resolution passed during the conference expressed deep disappointment with the WHO’s estimates, which are significantly higher than the official death toll reported by Indian authorities. The ministers highlighted India’s robust death registration system, governed by the “Registration of Births and Deaths Act 1969,” which ensures accurate and systematic documentation of deaths.
The health ministers have called upon India’s Health Minister, Mansukh Mandaviya, to take appropriate action in response to these concerns. They have also urged the central government to address the issue with the WHO on a global scale, emphasizing the importance of accurate and reliable data in understanding the impact of the pandemic.
In conclusion, India’s health ministers have come together to challenge the WHO’s estimates of COVID-19-related deaths, asserting that India’s systematic and transparent death registration system provides a more accurate representation of the situation. The dispute highlights the critical role of accurate data in understanding and responding to the challenges posed by the pandemic.